Most guessers were pretty much in the ballpark of reality. Some of the numbers that were thrown out, however, kinda cracked me up. I've been quite busy this year but couldn't imagine being busy enough to crank out 1999, 762 or 817 handmade plushies in a year's time. Maybe if I were able to sew and build full time I could hit those sorts of stats, but not on top of my full time day job. It is food for thought, though. Your confidence in me is much appreciated - and I hope that I haven't let you down.
Here's how some of the 2009 numbers shook out:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/974b6/974b6cd7db1eadff32db3d00b642336bbd386a24" alt=""
Etsy.Com (195)
Donations and Gifts (29)
Bizarre Bazaar/Maker Faire (25)
Renegade San Francisco (89)
That's a lot of this:
A lot of this:
A BUNCH of this:
And a little bit of this:
There were some other numbers including stock left at the end of the year and things sent to brick and mortar shops. The final-final number is probably slightly under reported but my best guesstimate based upon the numbers that I had.
So my big number is: 368
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53a68/53a6881af80f2152c453ad59d7b7db27757e726d" alt=""
Which means that the Big Winner is: Alyssa of AlliesAdornments - the maker of absolutely beautiful jewelry that she creates from upcycled and repurposed to-die-for vintage buttons. (She guessed 367).
Thanks again to EVERYONE for playing along with this little contest and most importantly for supporting me with such heart as I pursued this creative endeavor over the past couple of years.
Its been real. And, it has been fun.
Now? Now it is time to clear off that baby changing table and make room for the next great adventure!
Not to fear, the shop does not have a closing date - but things are slowing down. We are hoping for news of our adoption hopes and dreams becoming a reality by the end of the summer this year. So, we'll see what happens between then and now. Probably a lot more gardening, maybe some quilt making and definitely some projects around the house!!
xo